Seeing double: students design for contested land in Informal Cities workshop
2026-11-19 • Caitlin Custer
How can designers make contested land — territory seen in different ways between different groups — visible, without claiming to settle it, speak it, or own it?
This was the challenge for undergraduate and graduate students participating in this year’s Informal Cities workshop, which focused on Suba, a densely populated locality on the northwestern edge of Bogotá, Colombia. The workshop opened with a lecture from María M. Jaramillo Garcés, former secretary of planning for the capital city and founder and executive director of LACPlan . She introduced participants to the territory, sharing how Bogotá’s planning tradition produced disasters by refusing to understand the knowledge it was building over, the knowledge of the indigenous Muisca who have lived in the territory for millennia.
Addressing the workshop’s title, Jaramillo carefully redefined the terms “formal” and “informal.” For her, formality is a practice, a particular way of seeing, measuring, and governing land. Informal, on the other hand, “is what that practice cannot register: a territory lived and ordered from another cosmovision, the Muisca’s, whose law of origin, sacred sites, and relations to water, wind, and the dead, have a form — rigorous, inherited, binding — that simply does not appear in the city’s instruments,” she shared. “Informal, then, does not mean lacking form. It means holding a form that formality does not recognize.”
The weekend workshop was divided into three design challenges, with participants working together in small groups. To start, they drew on paper to show spatial features, occupation pathways, and planning designations that govern the site. From there, each group used cardboard to build the site’s terrain, then model the seam where the two knowledges meet, capturing what the planning perspective leaves out and showing forces, claims, and silences that surround it. The final task was to continue working and drawing, either on the model or beyond, designing interventions to illustrate the contested nature of the territory and to make each logic visible to the other group, without fusing them.
“None of us wanted to fall into generalizations or propose ideas that seemed out of touch,” Josep Campoy, MArch/MUD ’28, said. “Nevertheless, the process of quickly familiarizing ourselves with the area…followed by the construction of an abstract site model using recycled materials, allowed us to distill the site down to what we considered most important. Translating these ideas into a physical model revealed that the layers underlying Suba’s informality extend far beyond immediate necessity. They embody decades of indigenous settlement, colonization, and modern infrastructural development, some of which now appear fragmented or obsolete within the urban fabric.” Campoy also noted the freedom of not having to immediately translate their observations into a design decision or work towards a predetermined outcome. By developing their ideas more organically, they were able to engage with Suba through a process of discovery rather than immediate resolution.
Paulina Ramirez, MArch ’27, said that what surprised her most “was discovering how informality generates its own internal logic and how informal conditions foster some of the most resourceful design solutions.” She plans to carry this approach into her career by“learning to lead with freedom, stay experimental, and create frameworks that elevate rather than erase informal dynamics,” she said.
The workshop emphasized designing from a more honest and modest perspective, producing work that makes contested ground legible as such. To close, participants brought their work together to form a model of the entire site, with the goal of creating a work that allows a viewer to stand at the seam and understand that the ground is claimed twice.
“The collective installation of all works — ‘Contested Ground: Designing at the Epistemic Edge of Bogotá’ — forms not a shared vision but a shared act of acknowledgment,” Jaramillo shared. “Every city has an edge like Suba’s. The question for our discipline is whether we can learn to see it before we draw over it.”
About María M. Jaramillo Garcés
María M. Jaramillo Garcés is a strategic leader in sustainable urban and regional development with over 20 years of experience across Latin America and Europe. As CEO of RenoBO, Bogotá’s public land bank, she oversaw urban renewal and land readjustment in the heart of the capital. As secretary of planning for Bogotá (2021–23), she directed the Bogotá Reverdece 2022-35 Land Use Plan — the master plan that, for the first time in the city’s history, recognized the Muisca System of Sacred Sites as a stepping stone for planning — and co-designed and institutionalized Bogotá’s Care System and Monetary Transfer System, serving 3.5 million people and keeping 500,000 out of poverty during the COVID-19 pandemic. Her work in office included a transformative intercultural dialogue with the Muisca indigenous community of the city’s northwestern edge — the same contested ground this workshop examines. A Harvard Mason Fellow (MPA, 2025) and Loeb Fellow at the Graduate School of Design (2023-24), she founded LACPlan to build the governance, planning, and leadership frameworks Latin America and the Caribbean need to address their most urgent transnational challenges — climate, migration, peace, and security — at the continental scale they demand.